EST. 2003 FAMILY OWNED

Authentic New York-style
pizza

Hand-tossed thin crust, made fresh when you order. Family recipes from Brooklyn & New Jersey.

Tue–Thu 4–8 · Fri–Sat 11–9 · Sun 12–8 · Closed Monday

4.5
Yelp · 200+ reviews
20+
Years of pizza
2003
Family owned
Local
Neighborhood favorite
SINCE 2003

A family tradition from the East Coast.

Fratelli’s is an independent, family-owned pizzeria. We’ve been making pies here since 2003.

We make our dough daily from scratch and cook our own sauces. We even blend our own salad dressings. Nothing sits under a heat lamp: every pie, hoagie, and order of garlic knots is made when you order it.

The recipes come from family who ran pizza parlors in Brooklyn and New Jersey for more than 30 years. We brought that foldable New York thin crust here — crisp bottom, bold sauce, quality toppings — baked in our Bakers Pride ovens.

Flour, house tomato sauce, and dough trays at the Fratelli's pizza station
MADE TO ORDER
Dough, sauce, and pies
from scratch every day.
FOR EVERY OCCASION

Catering made easy.

Office lunches, game days, and family gatherings — trays, salads, and pies made to order.

  • Trays of pasta, salads & wings
  • Custom pizza orders (build your own or signature)
  • 24–48 hour advance notice preferred
Call (513) 777-5061
Catering orders by phone only (24–48 hrs notice preferred)
Hand-stretched dough with house tomato sauce spiraled on a wooden board
Perfect for any amount of people
VISIT US

Come see us.

ADDRESS
6890 Tylersville Road
West Chester, OH 45069
HOURS
Closed Mondays
Tuesday – Thursday: 4PM – 8PM
Friday – Saturday: 11AM – 9PM
Sunday: 12PM – 8PM
Dining room may close 30 minutes before kitchen.
Dining room at Fratelli's Pizzeria in West Chester

Dine-in and takeout

LOVED BY LOCALS

The regulars keep coming back.

Friday family pickups, after-practice pies, and the same faces week after week. Twenty years of that kind of love.

4.5
on Yelp
200+
customer reviews
20+
years of regulars
Read Google reviews Read Yelp reviews

Ready for pizza night?

Hand-tossed pies, made fresh when you order. Pickup in minutes.

Order for Pickup
Order for Pickup Call